Senji (senji) wrote,
Senji
senji

  • Mood:

More through luck than ring-lore, and discussions on CCGs

I spent the weekend playing CCGs. Lord of the Rings CCG on Saturday and Netrunner on Sunday. I did abysmally in the Netrunner tourney (of 5, APA), which was a bit sad.

The LotR I'd been drafted into to make up numbers, and consisted of a draft and a constructed tourney - one of the other players played my enterance fee and ended up with my cards. Lots of fun, particularly since I came 4th and 2nd respectively.

It's a better game than it might've been, but it provides a good vantage point for my favourite rant in the area - Card Art. Card Art is important, it helps to draw people in, and helps make mediocre games playable. Decipher have done a generally good job with their cards, but there are places where I think they could've done better. For instance, the game currently has 5 cards depicting Éowyn - [1] [2] [3] [4] [5]. The first of this is a Promo card, so isn't generally available. Now, (and this is all IMHO from this point on), Number 5 out of that lot is the image that best portraies Éowyn, either as Tolkien presents her, or as she's presented in the film - however, it is obvious why they picked it for the Éowyn's Sword picture.

3 and 4 both give unflattering images of her - these are the Éowyn cards in the standard Two Towers set, and even 2 isn't an amazingly good picture; I remember better ones from the film (particularly from the Helm's Deep sections, and since 2 is from the Helm's Deep expansion I'd expect to see a picture from that part of the film there. As you might have gathered by now, 1 is the only Éowyn card that I actually like, and that's entirely on the strength of the picture - the thematics of the card are wrong; that picture would go better with the Daughter of Éomund (2) card-text - since it presents a different side of her character than the 'usual' one.

They could also have done a better job of matching flavour-text up with pictures, but... *shrugs*. Éowyn is just an example though - I could make similar disections of the Arwen and Aragorn cards (although I saw a less representative collection of those while playing), and probably others as well...
Subscribe

  • By their accessories shall thee know them.

    I assume that, somewhere — perhaps nestled in the Square Mile, the serious British City Gent still wears his bowler hat and black umbrella and…

  • Win!

    Since one of the early heavy rains, which entered the house via the window near my desk and assaulted my Kensington ExpertMousePro the top-left and…

  • ...and a very scary solstice to Mrs Trellis of South Wales...

    It looks like I'm already too late for this to be anything but "…in other news, Princess of Wales still dead…" but since I'm…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic
    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 0 comments